The Best Years of Our Lives (1946)

This week we take a sharp left turn from our usual cinematic diet of Tombs of the Blind Dead, Maniac Cop, and Tango & Cash to talk about a genuine masterpiece of American filmmaking. Yes, the same podcast that once "recommended" Raiders of the Living Dead with a straight(ish) face is now asking you to sit down for a three‑hour post‑WWII drama about ordinary people trying to rebuild their lives.And it’s worth every minute.William Wyler’s The Best Years of Our Lives still resonates with a grounded emotional honesty that’s hard to find; especially in the kinds of movies we usually bring to the table. You won’t find a single bullet, a Reb Brown scream, a spiked shoulder pad, or anyone cutting pizza with scissors. What you will find is a film that takes the “boring parts” of action movies: talking, relationships, consequences, and makes them riveting through sharp writing and extraordinary performances.This is a movie that trusts its actors to carry three hours of humanity, vulnerability, and quiet power. And they do.Directed by: William Wyler (1946)Starring:

Myrna Loy as Milly StephensonFredric March as Technical Sergeant Al StephensonDana Andrews as Captain Fred DerryTeresa Wright as Peggy StephensonVirginia Mayo as Marie DerryCathy O’Donnell as Wilma CameronWhit Bissell Award Winner Hoagy Carmichael as Butch EngleHarold Russell as Petty Officer 2nd Class Homer ParrishGladys George as Hortense DerryRoman Bohnen as Pat DerryWhit Bissell Award Winner Marlene Aames as Luella ParrishIf you’re not in the mood for three hours of talking, we get it—we’ve got over 200 other movies to suggest. But if you’re willing to try something infinitely less bloody and probably more thoughtful, this one is well worth your time.Maybe it’s a little too cute, a little too uplifting, and maybe it only shows three very specific walks of life that (spoilers) turn out pretty well. But maybe we need a movie like that. Maybe we need something that isn’t cartoonishly cynical for shock value, something that actually thinks about its subject. Less than a year after WWII ended, this film dared to talk about things people weren’t ready to talk about.We’ve thrown around the phrase “perfect movie” before, but what we really mean is a movie you finish and think: no notes. That’s subjective, sure. Nothing is truly perfect. But for two guys who would otherwise recommend Psycho Goreman without blinking, this film is as close as it gets because of how it can reach us anyway.We hope you find it, watch it, and enjoy it as much as we did.Thanks as always for listening—and we’ll see you next time._____________

Matt has over 100+ lists for movie suggestions on ⁠⁠Letterboxd⁠⁠

You can reach out on Bluesky: @MovieMattSirois Terrible movies often find him, even under under the alias Marcus at ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Movie Asylum of the Weird, Bad and Wonderful⁠⁠.

Follow who we follow at the ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Once Upon a Geek⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and  ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠TheFade Out Podcast⁠⁠⁠s