OLLY Agentic Commerce Optimization: MarTech & Digital Compliance Director Jennifer Peters On Building an AI Foundation the Right Way

In this episode, we sit down with Jennifer Peters, Director of DTC, MarTech & Digital Compliance at OLLY, on building an AEO foundation the right way: FAQs and catalog attributes, measuring agentic visibility, and staying human-centered in a regulated CPG world.

We start with a Shopify “side quest”, how a self-taught developer ended up in AI god mode with Claude and MCP, before getting into what OLLY actually is and why a brand that does most of its revenue in-store suddenly cares so much about its website.

Jennifer has been quietly building one of the most grounded, real-world Agentic Commerce playbooks we've heard on the show. She shares the basics done tightly and gives a clear-eyed take on what's worth investing in while the ground shifts week to week.

It’s a grounded, refreshingly un-hyped conversation about building for the agentic era without losing your head, or your customers. Hit play.

Highlights: 

• The cold-resource, high-impact win: Jennifer on catalog feed enhancement.
• The FAQ slam dunk: OLLY added FAQs to its PDPs using content already on the page, just repackaged into bite-sized chunks. LLMs love the format, and so do humans.
• AEO is just good SEO: Clean up your schemas, clean up your data structure, and do the things that are good for your brand anyway.
• Attributes Google never asked for: A partner ingests OLLY’s public catalog and pushes back AI-ready attributes, none of them customer-facing.
• The website is now the point of entry: A site that was “7 or 8% of the business” is now the brand authority source agents go to first, for OLLY’s own site, Walmart’s Sparky, and Amazon’s Rufus.
• Trust but verify: OLLY triangulates recommendations across Profound, Contentsquare, and Envive. If all three flag the same thing, it’s probably worth acting on.
• Don’t “do AI to do AI”: “We’re not changing the goals because we have AI. We’re keeping the goals and just doing a better job getting to them.” Same OKRs, just faster.
• Fix the un-AI basics first: Connect your DAM, your creative stack, and your marketing stack before you try to sprinkle AI magic on top. Scot adds that AI can be the excuse to finally get it prioritized.
• The AI bubble in the bubble: From San Francisco, Jennifer on the coming counterculture: “No AI in our creative” as a selling point, growing data center backlash, and Ronny Chieng’s Harvard commencement speech.

Jennifer is exactly the kind of hands-on practitioner this show exists to find: strategic, tactical, and refreshingly honest about what’s real and what’s noise. We’ll have to get her back in a year to see what other magical (and weird) things she’s figured out. 

Enjoy the conversation.

Timestamps:
00:00 Cold open — lowest resource, highest impact
00:21 Welcome to Retailgentic
01:36 Scot's intro: a real practitioner doing the work
04:13 Welcome, Jennifer Peters
05:20 Jennifer's background: agency, Cokesbury, OLLY
06:51 Becoming a self-taught Shopify developer
07:56 Side quest: Claude, MCP, and AI "god mode"
11:34 What is OLLY? The square-bottle homeland
12:18 Inside the DTC + MarTech role
13:15 Why the website is now the point of entry
16:21 Jennifer's agentic commerce journey begins
17:48 Start with the basics: AEO is just good SEO
18:21 FAQs on PDPs — the easy slam dunk
19:48 Catalog feed enhancement & digital attributes
21:52 Profound and the AEO vendor landscape
23:57 Panel data: "super sus"
24:42 Trust but verify across tools
25:45 The Reddit problem
27:14 Bazaarvoice and review syndication
28:44 Don't skip the un-AI basics
30:20 Measuring impact without getting fooled
31:31 Same OKRs, AI just gets there faster
35:40 Does it leak into Walmart & Target?
37:48 Sharing content across channels
40:06 What's next: AI backlash and counterculture
42:37 Where to find Jennifer & outro

👉 Connect with Jennifer: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jennifer-peters-3bbb6220/
👉 Learn more about Olly: https://www.olly.com/

🧠 Want to stay ahead in AI commerce? Subscribe and follow along:
📰 Subscribe to the free Substack: retailgentic.ai
📺 Watch episodes on YouTube & Subscribe for updates: https://www.youtube.com/@Retailgentic